Log In


Reset Password
LEHIGH VALLEY WEATHER

Group seeks cost data

More than 100 Bethlehem Area School District students, parents, residents, taxpayers, educators and community leaders have signed an open letter urging the district to conduct a comprehensive financial analysis before narrowing options that could include school closures.

The letter, “Closure Discussions Are Moving Ahead of the Evidence,” asks BASD to address six priorities, including exploring alternatives to closures, determining their full financial impact, comparing schools consistently and considering neighborhood effects.

Organizers say some schools, including Thomas Jefferson and William Penn elementary schools, have faced greater public scrutiny because of previous discussions about renovation, replacement, consolidation or closure.

Although BASD has released enrollment figures, capital improvement estimates and districtwide financial information, organizers contend the available materials lack consistent comparisons of long-term costs per student. They want those comparisons to include capital investments, transportation, building maintenance, operations and staffing.

“Neither smaller enrollment nor major investments due now establish that a school is more expensive per student over the long term,” said Dan Sobrinski, a BASD parent and community member. “A consistent cost baseline should inform which scenarios advance; detailed feasibility studies can follow.”

BASD is preparing to select five scenarios for further evaluation. Organizers are concerned that options could be eliminated before their long-term financial implications are fully considered.

The letter outlines six priorities:

1. Explore alternatives: Examine funding opportunities and other options before determining closures are necessary.

2. Calculate full costs: Include transportation, transition expenses, infrastructure needs and other financial effects.

3. Compare schools fairly: Evaluate long-term operating and capital costs over at least 20 years.

4. Address excess capacity: Consider districtwide planning decisions without unfairly burdening individual neighborhoods.

5. Value neighborhood schools: Account for walkability, transportation, family participation and community impacts.

6. Examine previous closures: Consider cumulative effects on neighborhoods, transportation and the district’s presence in Bethlehem’s urban core.

Organizers emphasize that signers are not necessarily supporting or opposing any particular school closure. Rather, they want decisions based on consistent financial evidence and transparent criteria.

“BASD has built a school district with much to be proud of,” said George Wacker, a BASD parent and community member. “We should approach these decisions from that position of strength, fully examine the options available to sustain what is working, and make structural changes only when the evidence shows they are necessary.”

Organizers have requested a written response from BASD and offered to meet with district officials and school board members.

For information, contact BASD Community Voices at BASDCommunityVoices@gmail.com.

Contributed article