Hanover Township Rt. 512 Turkey Hill to remain dry
You can buy a nice chiinti at Wegmans or Weis. But by a 3 to 1 vote at their May 9 meeting, Hanover Township Ssupervisors voted down the proposed transfer of a liquor license to a Turkey Hill gas station located at Sterners Way and Route 512. Mark Tanczos, who owns a beer distributorship, recused himself. The sole Yes vote was cast by John Diacogiannis. Jack Nagle, Steve Salvesen and Michael Prendeville voted no.
Each supervisor explained his vote. Salvesen said he supported alcohol sales at Wegmans and Weis because there was testimony that there would be 24-hour supervision of the alcoholic beverages sold there, but no such assurance was made by Turkey Hill, a gas station that hires part-time people. He said there were too many avenues for abuse.
Nagle said it comes down to common sense and thinking about the “health and wellbeing of our township.” He said that, contrary to testimony offered at a hearing two weeks before, a convenience store like Turkey Hill really is a destination for people who want to get a quick can of soda or jug of milk. He said permitting alcohol sales at a gas station “goes totally against what’s been going on in this nation for the last 30 years, with Mothers Against Drunk Driving and the National Transportation Safety Authority. ... For me, to permit alcohol to be consumed at a place that dispenses gasoline is literally like throwing gasoline on a fire.”
Prendeville said the density of alcohol licenses “contributes in a very detrimental way to neighborhoods.” He said he would be uncomfortable sending his children to get a gallon of milk at Turkey Hill at 1 am and have them compete against people trying to buy and drink alcohol at a gas station because other bars have closed. “The potential risk far outweighs any reward in my mind,” he concluded. “It has the potential to introduce problems that have already overburdened our police department and first responders.”
Diacogiannis, unlike his fellow supervisors, supported the liquor license transfer. He reasoned that the state legislature has expanded sales to gas stations. “This decision has already been made by the state,” he said. “It’s really not our part to make these decisions.”
Finnigan later noted that there were also concerns whether parking would be adequate for this new use, but there was no plan to review.
Though supervisors denied the liquor license transfer, they unanimously approved changes to their zoning ordinance that would permit distilleries, brew pubs and wineries at certain places within the township. Solicitor Jim Broughal explained the reason for this ordinance. “If you don’t put this in your ordinance, your neighbor can put a distillery in his house,” he explained. “You are required by law to provide for every use we know about. If you don’t, it’s exclusionary zoning.”
They also adopted an ordinance banning invasive bamboo, joining a number of other Lehigh Valley municipalities that have followed Bethlehem Township’s lead in banning or regulating this legal immigrant from southeast China.
Invasive or running bamboo is actually a grass and is recognized by the Pa. Department of Conservation and Natural Resources as one of the fastest growing and most invasive plants in the world. Throughout Pennsylvania, 19 communities have adopted bamboo ordinances. Some, like Douglass Township, have imposed a ban on this grass.
A Cumberland County Court has declared running bamboo a “vegetative nuisance” The court reasoned that urban living includes certain responsibilities, including a responsibility to take precautions against invasive plants that encroach upon another person’s property.
Supervisors endorsed the bamboo ban in a 4 to 1 vote. Once again, Diacogiannis was the sole dissenter. He called it an “invasion of individual property rights.” He said this is a matter that neighbors should handle between themselves, although some neighbors can be unreasonable. He said he doesn’t like invasive bamboo, either, but is opposed to an ordinance “for every single little thing.”
“I’m planting it!” joked a resident who earlier that evening had complained about an unreasonable neighbor.
On an unusually busy night, supervisors also approved the vacation of paper streets laid out on property owned by the Earl Kunsman family, near Bath Pike. Bethlehem Attorney Jim Holzinger advised supervisors that he was unable to ascertain that these roads ever existed or were accepted by the township,but are referred to in the deeds.
Finally, Bill Vogler asked upervisors to do something about sinkholes. He acknowledged “we live on Swiss cheese,” but said sinkholes caused by water main breaks are different than those that occur naturally. Several water companies have infrastructure in the township, according to Diacogiannis.
Vogler and Finnigan discussed the situation after the meeting.








