Mayor eyes a 2.9% tax increase
Mayor J. William Reynolds presented his proposed $110 million 2027 budget the morning of Nov. 6, the first event held at the new ArtsQuest Creative Factory, an as-yet unfinished structure towering over the former Banana Factory lot.
The proposal includes a 2.9 percent property tax increase and a proposed recycling fee increase of approximately $1.67 per month, while describing long-term successes in reducing debt, funding pensions and managing rising health care costs.
“We’ve made incredible financial progress, we’re investing in our community, we investing in our city, and we’re doing it in an honest and reliable way,” Reynolds said. “There are rules that we have to follow in the City of Bethlehem when we do our budgets, and we’re thinking about things. It starts with this idea that you need sustainable revenues to pay sustainable expenses … I know that some of you live in townships and municipalities and school districts and other areas [where] rule number one does not get followed. One of the things we have always done in the City of Bethlehem is been like, ‘it’s better to pay a few dollars this year than have to pay a whole lot of money in a couple years.’”
He spoke at length about onetime infusions of cash, such as from the federal government, and “irresponsibly” using them to prop up expenses in the short term and then having to raise taxes every year. Unlike other municipalities, Reynolds said, Bethlehem typically raises taxes by small amounts every few years. Most recently, increases were made in 2018, 2019, 2021, 2024 and next year.
Reynolds said the big expenses include debt, employee pensions and health care, emergency services and recycling efforts.
The first, debt, is in good shape, he said, from $171 million to $71 million, and refinancing allows 2027 debt payments to decrease by $1 million. It is, “incredible when you take a look at what the world has been through over the past 12 years.”
Likewise pensions are 96 percent funded, with payments falling by about $332.000.
Salaries will increase $3.1 million next year, and, unfortunately like the rest of the country, the city must contend with skyrocketing health care costs.
“This medical thing is not going away,” Reynolds said of a $2 million increase, though he couched good health care as a necessity for being a good employer and getting people to work for the city.
A former teacher, Reynolds wanted to “show the work” about the recycling fee.
“Unfortunately, the cost of recycling has continued to increase while our revenues from recycling have continued to decrease.” He said contracts increase annually and the recyclables market has dried up, falling from $855,000 in 2011, paying for 30 percent of its own expenses, to only $60,000 in 2025. “We need to find other ways to pay for that.”
On the recommendation of the Fraternal Order of Police, Reynolds is also proposing a police salary increase. He said this is particularly important as it is the city department most difficult to staff. Part of a nationwide trend, he said they may hire three officers a year against five retirements.
The budget also adds two paramedic and two firefighter positions.
“Three-quarters of our budget is public safety,” Reynolds added. “The number one thing people look at when they are looking at paying their taxes is, ‘is my community safe.’ And Bethlehem, year after year after year, is the safest community around. We are the safest midsize city in Pennsylvania. You see that from when you have all these surveys about why do people move here, why do they stay here, why do they let their kids walk to school. They look at our community and they say this is a safe community.”








