Another QB, another loss for Birds
Another quarterback, another loss.
“Bazooka” Joe Milton had the chance to begin a new burst for the Eagles, but it wasn’t long until the Birds’ bubble burst. Milton had an average performance, but you couldn’t have expected too much from a guy who was with the team for a little over three weeks.
It was another disastrous performance from the offensive line that allowed seven sacks, and the defense - especially the secondary - looked worn down in the second half. The pass rush looked revived, but Jordan Davis got shipped to Jacksonville.
Northampton assistant head coach and former Palisades head coach Kevin Ronalds, Catasauqua quarterbacks’ coach and former Northampton quarterback Cooper King, Whitehall softball coach Jeff Vivian, Freedom golf coach Mike Evans, and Lehigh Valley Press sports editor Scott Pagel will all offer their views and opinions on Eagles’ issues in this week’s Eagles’ Roundtable.
In this week’s discussion the panel will look at Milton, the pass rush, the offensive line, the safety situation, and whether the Eagles will continue to peel off pieces.
(They responded before the Davis trade.)
How would you rate Milton’s performance?
Ronalds - “Joe Milton brought some energy, especially early in the game. He was willing to make plays with his legs and extend plays. He was also inconsistent, and still only put eight points on the board. In the end, he deserves more time for a true evaluation, but I don’t think anyone will mistake Milton for a long term Eagles QB. Having said that, it is also a difficult debut behind the current Eagles offensive line and lack of running game.”
King - “He showed mobility and some promise, but struggled passing and reading pressure. The blocking and drops didn’t help. Give him more starts before judging him.”
Vivian - “Milton’s performance was about what was expected with a gig arm and no accuracy. And while he has more mobility than (Tanner) McKee, he is just limited in sustaining drives, especially in this offense with this offensive line.”
Evans - “Milton had some good looking plays but definitely struggled in the new offense for him. He’s very athletic and will likely improve with more reps under center.”
Pagel - “I made the mistake of thinking Milton would be a lot better than he was, but that’s me just being an Eagles fan. I thought his mobility would make a bigger difference. I do think there is a learning curve for him, and I’ll be curious to see if he can improve over the next couple of games. I think he could be the team’s backup QB going forward if we can see some progress.”
Did the pass rush redeem itself or was the Giants’ running game bad?
Ronalds - “The Eagles defense was a bright spot. Many sacks and tackles for loss were recorded in the game. The Giants are struggling with many similar issues as the Eagles (injuries to key players, etc.), but you still have to stop them. The Eagles did that for most of the game.
“The defensive line was dominant. Unfortunately, they have to be almost perfect to win because of the lack of offense.”
King - “Both. The Giants’ weakened running game helped, but the Eagles’ defensive front genuinely played better. The secondary still had costly breakdowns.”
Vivian - “The defense played well but again was on the field way too long and ended up being exposed. The Giants’ line is only slightly better than the eagles which says a lot about NFC East.”
Evans - “The defensive line looked pretty solid, just didn’t get a lot of pressures on the QB. I’d like to see more blitz packages.”
Pagel - “I thought the defense did a nice job. (Devin) Singletary has had his moments in the league and they shut down the running game like we haven’t seen in quite some time. (Quinyon) Mitchell did a pretty good job on (Malik) Nabers too. So overall I can say I was happy with the performance and I’m hopeful they can keep it going. Again, I don’t think the offense does them any favors with time of possession.”
Can the offensive line ever be fixed?
Ronalds - “The offensive line is an organizational issue at this point, and will not get solved in season. This has to be solved with draft picks and a free agent signing or two. The upcoming trade deadline can hurt the line in season, but can help for next season by adding picks.”
King - “Fixable, but not overnight. Better protection calls and quicker passes could help now. Personnel and coaching changes may be needed long-term.”
Vivian - “The regression on this offensive line speaks volumes about Jeff Stoutland and what he accomplished with it. They need to address it in the off-season with either free agents or draft picks...but I am not sure they have the staff to bring some of these guys back to what they were.”
Evans - ‘The offensive line has struggled severely and if we want any future success we have to start with our draft picks and develop some good O-lineman. It’s clearly the Achilles heel of this offense.”
Pagel - “I will continue to say the O-line can get better with time and experience, but I’m not sure the ceiling is that high for this group overall. But as I’ve said a few weeks ago, I think the O-line is one of several areas we’ll see an overhaul. It’s been a staple of this organization for as long as I can remember and I think they believe this is where games are won.”
Can the struggling safety position be fixed?
Ronalds - “The safety position is another off season issue. They need to spend the rest of this season evaluating (Andrew) Mukuba to see if he is a player they feel can improve and be the kind of player they thought, or cut ties with him and look elsewhere. Also, (Cooper) DeJean hasn’t been as effective this season as he was his rookie season. That could be because he has moved around the defense so much this season.”
King - “They can improve by communicating better and cutting assignment mistakes. But coaching alone might not solve the talent problem. (Cooper) DeJean does not look as sharp as he did last year.”
Vivian - “The safety situation and the second cornerback spot has been a glaring issue all year. Having a pass rush helps but when the rush doesn’t get there it’s a spot that’s been exposed.”
Evans - “The safeties don’t seem to have too much of a problem. I’m not really worried there, more so worried about the defensive scheme and needing to lock it down.”
Pagel - “With all the draft picks being acquired, I think safety will be another area the team fixes going forward. With the trade of Davis on Monday, and who knows what happens Tuesday before the deadline, the secondary could be in for a rough second half of the season if they continue to take away from the pass rush that has barely been there anyway. I don’t think it’s fixed this year but it has to be an area they address in the offseason.”
Will the Eagles be sellers, and who should go?
Ronalds - “Having already seen Jordan Davis gone, the Eagles are sellers. There will be others. It is hard to predict who else will be moved, it may be easier to guess who is off the table. I think Howie Roseman would listen to offers for almost anyone. Players he would not want to move would be; Mitchell, DeJean, (Nolan) Smith, (Makei) Lemon, (Jalen) Carter, and (Jordan) Mailata.”
King - “The Eagles should be selective sellers, though deals aren’t confirmed. I think they should listen on (Riq) Woolen, (Landon) Dickerson and (Dallas) Goedert, but don’t give them away.”
Vivian - “The Eagles may move on a player (Moro Ojomo or another defensive tackle), but I don’t think they will sell off everything. The NFC East is so bad right now.”
Evans - “The Eagles will absolutely be sellers, and I think wide receiver Dontayvion Wicks and linebacker Zach Baun might be two key guys that might go unfortunately.”
Pagel - “I don’t think the team is intending to rebuild and I don’t think they will ever call it that publicly even if they are, but I do think they have some smaller pieces to sell. It seems like they are going to keep Barkley, but guys like Dallas Goedert, Riq Woolen and Hollywood Brown I think could go in smaller deals. The Eagles will have a lot of flexibility with all these picks to trade up or even trade for players, like they did when they traded for A.J. Brown during the draft.”
My take - “It’s time for the Eagles to blow this up as much as they can. There’s no guarantee Jalen Hurts will be back next season, or that he will ever play again with more blood clots found. Bell and Jordan Mailata should be the only mainstays on the O-line. Roseman will keep a base, but he likely will do his best to get into the college football quarterback and offensive line derby. Adding another first-round pick for Davis was a start. Milton can play his way into a backup role for next season.”
Thanks to coaches Kevin Ronalds, Cooper King, Jeff Vivian, Mike Evans bossman Scott Pagel for sharing their thoughts this week.
However, you, too, can join us. Simply send an email to tnsports@tnonline with the title “Eagles Roundtable,” and if your email is chosen, we’ll include you in our weekly discussion! It’s that easy!
Your thoughts are always welcomed and will be published; email them to spagel@tnonline.com








